When You and I Were Young, Maggie | Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame
All inducted songs
Originally written as a poem to show his undying love to his fiancee who struggled with tuberculosis.
When You and I Were Young, Maggie
  • Year Inducted: 2005
  • Written In: 1866
George Washington Johnson Lyricist
James A. Butterfield Composer
Henry Burr
Harry MacDonough
John McCormack
Frank Mum
Benny Goodman
Tommy Ladnier
Red Nichols
Fats Waller
Teddy Wilson

One of the most popular ballads of the 19th and early 20th centuries with over 40 versions to its credit, When You and I Were Young, Maggie began as a love poem written by a school master, George Johnson, who taught in Glanford Township, south of Hamilton. In 1859, George, then 21, had fallen in love with one of his students, Margaret Clark, 18. After they were engaged, Margaret became ill with tuberculosis. He wrote the poem as a pledge of undying love and later had it published in a collection of his verse, titled Maple Leaves. George married his Maggie in 1864 but she had a relapse with the disease, dying in 1865, only seven months later. In 1866, George’s friend, James Butterfield, set the poem to music. When You and I Were Young, Maggie went on to become one of most popular songs on both sides of the Atlantic. The words and music were adopted in the Scottish burgh of Selkirk more than 100 years ago. In Ireland, the tune is sometimes known as Nora, from a Sean O’Casey play, The Ploughs and The Stars. George, who never benefited financially from the song, later became principal of Hamilton’s Central Public School and taught at Upper Canada College. He was also a professor at University of Toronto and at Cornell University. He later earned a PhD at Johns Hopkins University. George married three times but never forgot his beloved Maggie.

When You and I Were Young Maggie - Performed by Shaye
"When You and I Were Young Maggie", written and composed by George Washington Johnson and James A. Butterfield, was performed by Canadian pop trio Shaye at the 2005 CSHF Induction Gala.
Related News
May 28, 2024

Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame Announces 2024 Inductees: Tom Cochrane, Jim Cuddy and Greg Keelor (Blue Rodeo), Sarah McLachlan and Diane Tell

CSHF News, Media Releases
May 17, 2024

Bruce Cockburn: A Career in Review and the Future Sound of Music

Our Partners